The Marchex Blog

What’s Best for Your Business: Industry-Specific AI or General AI? Three questions to ask.

The Right Fit for Your Business

Everywhere you look, there’s buzz about AI Agents—a future where human employees work seamlessly with digital assistants. But when considering AI for your business, does “industry experience” of these agents matter? Experts argue that vertical-specific AI can deliver faster ROI (1, 2). But how do you decide if it’s essential for your needs or just a nice-to-have? 

Let’s break it down using a familiar example: tax software versus spreadsheets. During tax season, you could use Excel to do your taxes with enough time and skill. But wouldn’t you rather use software built to handle tax rules, updates, and nuances? Similarly, industry-specific AI typically comes pre-loaded with solutions tailored to your sector, but does that make it the best choice for your business? Here are three questions to ask:  

Question 1. Is the AI platform easy to set up?

Every AI solution requires some setup to work effectively for your business. But how much effort is too much? 

For instance, a dental office using a general AI tool to analyze its phone conversations might need to manually list phrases or keywords like “new patient exam” or “cleaning” to identify and prioritize leads. This can be time-consuming and leave room for errors or gaps in coverage. By contrast, industry-specific AI solutions come pre-trained with knowledge of specific phrases, topics, and even patterns relevant to dental practices. 

If your AI-powered analytics require excessive setup unrelated to your unique business details (e.g., which insurance providers a dental office accepts), an industry-specific solution might deliver better results. 

Question 2.  Does the platform require using your own deep industry expertise?

To be truly useful, your AI should generate insights and recommendations that can drive decisions. But how much industry knowledge does an AI agent need to be effective? 

Consider phone call analysis: a dental practice might prioritize leads interested in orthodontics, while an HVAC business might focus on homeowners with aging systems. A general AI tool often needs user guidance to fine-tune the analytics to identify these differences, requiring you to invest time and resources.

On the other hand, an industry-specific AI solution, would already have these nuances factored in. It would basically know what makes a lead valuable in your sector and integrate this into its analysis. If your AI analytics tool requires you to teach it industry knowledge to get started, a specialized application may be a better fit. 

Question 3. Can the AI adapt to industry changes?

Industries evolve—new regulations, customer concerns, and trends frequently emerge . Can your AI keep up without requiring constant manual updates? 

For example, an industry-specific AI trained on relevant phone conversations can automatically adapt to new customer priorities such as catching emerging treatments in healthcare or the latest product inquiries in auto services. A generic solution will struggle to stay relevant without ongoing manual updates. 

As businesses increasingly rely on AI as digital helpers alongside human teams (3), choosing tools that can grow with your industry becomes essential. An industry-specific solution is often better equipped to monitor both human and AI performance, ensuring every conversation can drive results. 

Are There Exceptions?

While most businesses can benefit from industry-specific AI, there are exceptions. Large enterprises with unique needs might prefer to develop their own AI models. Similarly, niche businesses without a close industry match could start with a general model and fine-tune it over time. In addition, the high cost of training a unique AI model and efforts involved in its maintenance could pull resources away from the company’s core mission.   

The Bottom Line: Efficiency Matters

You could use Excel to do your taxes, but wouldn’t tax software save time and reduce errors? The same applies to AI-powered solutions. A general model might work ok for any business, but industry-specific AI is typically built to do what you need—faster and with greater accuracy. 

When choosing an AI solution, consider prioritizing one that’s easy to set up, requires minimal upfront manual configuration, and can evolve alongside your industry. In most cases, the right fit is the one designed with your industry in mind. 

Explore industry-specific AI solutions for your businessGet a Demo!

 

  1. Forbes. “Verticalized GenAI Is Key to Enterprise-Level Successful Adoption.” Forbes. 
  2. Hyperight. “Modular AI vs. Vertical AI vs. Agentic AI: A Comparison.” Hyperight. 
  3. AIM Research. “Vertical AI Agents Will Dominate 2025.” AIM Research.